the divine institutes

 book i.

 preface.—of what great value the knowledge of the truth is and always has been.

 Chap. i.— of religion and wisdom.

 Chap. II.—That there is a providence in the affairs of men.

 Chap. III.—Whether the universe is governed by the power of one god or of many.

 Chap. IV.—That the one god was foretold even by the prophets.

 Chap. V.—Of the testimonies of poets and philosophers.

 Chap. VI.—Of divine testimonies, and of the sibyls and their predictions.

 chap. VII.—Concerning the testimonies of apollo and the gods.

 Chap. viii.—that god is without a body, nor does he need difference of sex for procreation.

 Chap. IX.—Of hercules and his life and death.

 Chap. X.—Of the life and actions of Æsculapius, apollo, neptune, mars, castor and pollux, mercury and bacchus.

 Chap. xi.—of the origin, life, reign, name and death of jupiter, and of saturn and uranus.

 Chap. xii.—that the stoics transfer the figments of the poets to a philosophical system.

 Chap. xiii.—how vain and trifling are the interpretations of the stoics respecting the gods, and in them concerning the origin of jupiter, concerning

 Chap. xiv.—what the sacred history of euhemerus and ennius teaches concerning the gods.

 Chap. xv.—how they who were men obtained the name of gods.

 Chap. xvi.— by what argument it is proved that those who are distinguished by a difference of sex cannot be gods.

 Chap. xvii.—concerning the same opinion of the stoics, and concerning the hardships and disgraceful conduct of the gods.

 Chap. xviii.—on the consecration of gods, on account of the benefits which they conferred upon men.

 Chap. xix.—that it is impossible for any one to worship the true god together with false deities.

 Chap. xx.—of the gods peculiar to the Romans, and their sacred rites.

 Chap. xxi.—of certain deities peculiar to barbarians, and their sacred rites and in like manner concerning the romans.

 Chap. xxii.—who was the author of the vanities before described in italy among the romans, and who among other nations.

 Chap. xxiii.—of the ages of vain superstitions, and the times at which they commenced.

 the divine institutes.

 Chap. i.—that forgetfulness of reason makes men ignorant of the true god, whom they worship in adversity and despise in prosperity.

 Chap. ii.—what was the first cause of making images of the true likeness of god, and the true worship of him.

 Chap. iii.—that cicero and other men of learning erred in not turning away the people from error.

 Chap. iv.—of images, and the ornaments of temples, and the contempt in which they are held even by the heathens themselves.

 Chap. v.—that god only, the creator of all things, is to be worshipped, and not the elements or heavenly bodies and the opinion of the stoics is refu

 Chap. vI.—that neither the whole universe nor the elements are god, nor are they possessed of life.

 Chap. vii.—of god, and the religious rites of the foolish of avarice, and the authority of ancestors.

 Chap. viii.—of the use of reason in religion and of dreams, auguries, oracles, and similar portents.

 Chap. ix.—of the devil, the world, god, providence, man, and his wisdom.

 Chap. X.—Of the World, and Its Parts, the Elements and Seasons.

 Chap. XI.—Of Living Creatures, of Man Prometheus, Deucalion, the ParcÆ.

 Chap. XII.—That Animals Were Not Produced Spontaneously, But by a Divine Arrangement, of Which God Would Have Given Us the Knowledge, If It Were Advan

 Chap. XIII.—Why Man is of Two Sexes What is His First Death, and What the Second and of the Fault and Punishment of Our First Parents.

 Chap. XIV.—Of Noah the Inventor of Wine, Who First Had Knowledge of the Stars, and of the Origin of False Religions.

 Chap. XV.—Of the Corruption of Angels, and the Two Kinds of Demons.

 Chap. XVI.—That Demons Have No Power Over Those Who are Established in the Faith.

 Chap. XVII.—That Astrology, Soothsaying, and Similar Arts are the Invention of Demons.

 Chap. XVIII.—Of the Patience and Vengeance of God, the Worship of Demons, and False Religions.

 Chap. XIX.—Of the Worship of Images and Earthly Objects.

 Chap. XX.—Of Philosophy and the Truth.

 the divine institutes

 Chap. I.—A Comparison of the Truth with Eloquence: Why the Philosophers Did Not Attain to It. Of the Simple Style of the Scriptures.

 Chap. II.—Of Philosophy, and How Vain Was Its Occupation in Setting Forth the Truth.

 Chap. III.—Of What Subjects Philosophy Consists, and Who Was the Chief Founder of the Academic Sect.

 Chap. IV.—That Knowledge is Taken Away by Socrates, and Conjecture by Zeno.

 Chap. V.—That the Knowledge of Many Things is Necessary.

 Chap. VI.—Of Wisdom, and the Academics, and Natural Philosophy.

 Chap. VII.—Of Moral Philosophy, and the Chief Good.

 Chap. VIII.—Of the Chief Good, and the Pleasures of the Soul and Body, and of Virtue.

 Chap. IX.—Of the Chief Good, and the Worship of the True God, and a Refutation of Anaxagoras.

 Chap. X.—It is the Peculiar Property of Man to Know and Worship God.

 Chap. XI.—Of Religion, Wisdom, and the Chief Good.

 Chap. XII.—Of the Twofold Conflict of Body and Soul And of Desiring Virtue on Account of Eternal Life.

 Chap. XIII.—Of the Immortality of the Soul, and of Wisdom, Philosophy, and Eloquence.

 Chap. XIV.—That Lucretius and Others Have Erred, and Cicero Himself, in Fixing the Origin of Wisdom.

 Chap. XV.—The Error of Seneca in Philosophy, and How the Speech of Philosophers is at Variance with Their Life.

 Chap. XVI.—That the Philosophers Who Give Good Instructions Live Badly, by the Testimony of Cicero Therefore We Should Not So Much Devote Ourselves t

 Chap. XVII.—He Passes from Philosophy to the Philosophers, Beginning with Epicurus And How He Regarded Leucippus and Democritus as Authors of Error.

 Chap. XVIII.—The Pythagoreans and Stoics, While They Hold the Immortality of the Soul, Foolishly Persuade a Voluntary Death.

 Chap. XIX.—Cicero and Others of the Wisest Men Teach the Immortality of the Soul, But in an Unbelieving Manner And that a Good or an Evil Death Must

 Chap. XX.—Socrates Had More Knowledge in Philosophy Than Other Men, Although in Many Things He Acted Foolishly.

 Chap. XXI.—Of the System of Plato, Which Would Lead to the Overthrow of States.

 Chap. XXII.—Of the Precepts of Plato, and Censures of the Same.

 Chap. XXIII.—Of the Errors of Certain Philosophers, and of the Sun and Moon.

 Chap. XXIV.—Of the Antipodes, the Heaven, and the Stars.

 Chap. XXV.—Of Learning Philosophy, and What Great Qualifications are Necessary for Its Pursuit.

 Chap. XXVI.—It is Divine Instruction Only Which Bestows Wisdom And of What Efficacy the Law of God is.

 Chap. XXVII.—How Little the Precepts of Philosophers Contribute to True Wisdom, Which You Will Find in Religion Only.

 Chap. XXVIII.—Of True Religion and of Nature. Whether Fortune is a Goddess, and of Philosophy.

 Chap. XXIX.—Of Fortune Again, and Virtue.

 Chap. XXX.—The Conclusion of the Things Before Spoken And by What Means We Must Pass from the Vanity of the Philosophers to True Wisdom, and the Know

 the divine institutes

 Chap. I.—Of the Former Religion of Men, and How Error Was Spread Over Every Age, and of the Seven Wise Men of Greece.

 Chap. II.—Where Wisdom is to Be Found Why Pythagoras and Plato Did Not Approach the Jews.

 Chap. III.—Wisdom and Religion Cannot Be Separated: the Lord of Nature Must Necessarily Be the Father of Every One.

 Chapter IV.—Of Wisdom Likewise, and Religion, and of the Right of Father and Lord.

 Chap. V.—The Oracles of the Prophets Must Be Looked Into And of Their Times, and the Times of the Judges and Kings.

 Chap. VI.—Almighty God Begat His Son And the Testimonies of the Sibyls and of Trismegistus Concerning Him.

 Chap. VII.—Of the Name of Son, and Whence He is Called Jesus and Christ.

 Chap. VIII.—Of the Birth of Jesus in the Spirit and in the Flesh: of Spirits and the Testimonies of Prophets.

 Chap. IX.—Of the Word of God.

 Chap. X.—Of the Advent of Jesus Of the Fortunes of the Jews, and Their Government, Until the Passion of the Lord.

 Chap. XI.—Of the Cause of the Incarnation of Christ.

 Chap. XII.—Of the Birth of Jesus from the Virgin Of His Life, Death, and Resurrection, and the Testimonies of the Prophets Respecting These Things.

 Chap. XIII.—Of Jesus, God and Man And the Testimonies of the Prophets Concerning Him.

 Chap. XIV.—Of the Priesthood of Jesus Foretold by the Prophets.

 Chap. XV.—Of the Life and Miracles of Jesus, and Testimonies Concerning Them.

 Chap. XVI.—Of the Passion of Jesus Christ That It Was Foretold.

 Chap. XVII.—Of the Superstitions of the Jews, and Their Hatred Against Jesus.

 Chap. XVIII.—Of the Lord’s Passion, and that It Was Foretold.

 Chap. XIX.—Of the Death, Burial, and Resurrection of Jesus And the Predictions of These Events.

 Chap. XX.—Of the Departure of Jesus into Galilee After His Resurrection And of the Two Testaments, the Old and the New.

 Chap. XXI.—Of the Ascension of Jesus, and the Foretelling of It And of the Preaching and Actions of the Disciples.

 Chap. XXII.—Arguments of Unbelievers Against the Incarnation of Jesus.

 Chap. XXIII.—Of Giving Precepts, and Acting.

 Chap. XXIV.—The Overthrowing of the Arguments Above Urged by Way of Objection.

 Chap. XXV.—Of the Advent of Jesus in the Flesh and Spirit, that He Might Be Mediator Between God and Man.

 Chap. XXVI.—Of the Cross, and Other Tortures of Jesus, and of the Figure of the Lamb Under the Law.

 Chap. XXVII.—Of the Wonders Effected by the Power of the Cross, and of Demons.

 Chap. XXVIII.—Of Hope and True Religion, and of Superstition.

 Chap. XXIX.—Of the Christian Religion, and of the Union of Jesus with the Father.

 Chap. XXX.—Of Avoiding Heresies and Superstitions, and What is the Only True Catholic Church.

 the divine institutes

 Chap. I.—Of the Non-Condemnation of Accused Persons Without a Hearing of Their Cause From What Cause Philosophers Despised the Sacred Writings Of th

 Chap. II.—To What an Extent the Christian Truth Has Been Assailed by Rash Men.

 Chap. III.—Of the Truth of the Christian Doctrine, and the Vanity of Its Adversaries And that Christ Was Not a Magician.

 Chap. IV.—Why This Work Was Published, and Again of Tertullian and Cyprian.

 Chap. V.—There Was True Justice Under Saturnus, But It Was Banished by Jupiter.

 Chap. VI.—After the Banishment of Justice, Lust, Unjust Laws, Daring, Avarice, Ambition, Pride, Impiety, and Other Vices Reigned.

 Chap. VII.—Of the Coming of Jesus, and Its Fruit And of the Virtues and Vices of that Age.

 Chap. VIII.—Of Justice Known to All, But Not Embraced Of the True Temple of God, and of His Worship, that All Vices May Be Subdued.

 Chap. IX.—Of the Crimes of the Wicked, and the Torture Inflicted on the Christians.

 Chap. X.—Of False Piety, and of False and True Religion.

 Chap XI.—Of the Cruelty of the Heathens Against the Christians.

 Chap. XII.—Of True Virtue And of the Estimation of a Good or Bad Citizen.

 Chapter XIII.—Of the Increase and the Punishment of the Christians.

 Chap. XIV.—Of the Fortitude of the Christians.

 Chap. XV.—Of Folly, Wisdom, Piety, Equity, and Justice.

 Chap. XVI.—Of the Duties of the Just Man, and the Equity of Christians.

 Chap. XVII.—Of the Equity, Wisdom, and Foolishness of Christians.

 Chap. XVIII.—Of Justice, Wisdom, and Folly.

 Chap. XIX.—Of Virtue and the Tortures of Christians, and of the Right of a Father and Master.

 Chap. XX.—Of the Vanity and Crimes, Impious Superstitions, and of the Tortures of the Christians.

 Chap. XXI.—Of the Worship of Other Gods and the True God, and of the Animals Which the Egyptians Worshipped.

 Chap. XXII.—Of the Rage of the Demons Against Christians, and the Error of Unbelievers.

 Chap. XXIII.—Of the Justice and Patience of the Christians.

 Chap. XXIV.—Of the Divine Vengeance Inflicted on the Torturers of the Christians.

 the divine institutes

 Chap. I.—Of the Worship of the True God, and of Innocency, and of the Worship of False Gods.

 Chap. II.—Of the Worship of False Gods and the True God.

 Chap. III.—Of the Ways, and of Vices and Virtues And of the Rewards of Heaven and the Punishments of Hell.

 Chap. IV.—Of the Ways of Life, of Pleasures, Also of the Hardships of Christians.

 Chap. V.—Of False and True Virtue And of Knowledge.

 Chap. VI.—Of the Chief Good and Virtue, and or Knowledge and Righteousness.

 Chap. VII.—Of the Way of Error and of Truth: that It is Single, Narrow, and Steep, and Has God for Its Guide.

 Chap. VIII.—Of the Errors of Philosophers, and the Variableness of Law.

 Chap. IX.—Of the Law and Precept of God Of Mercy, and the Error of the Philosophers.

 Chap. X.—Of Religion Towards God, and Mercy Towards Men And of the Beginning of the World.

 Chap. XI.—Of the Persons Upon Whom a Benefit is to Be Conferred.

 Chap. XII.—Of the Kinds of Beneficence, and Works of Mercy.

 Chap. XIII.—Of Repentance, of Mercy, and the Forgiveness of Sins.

 Chap. XIV.—Of the Affections, and the Opinion of the Stoics Respecting Them And of Virtue, the Vices, and Mercy.

 Chap. XV.—Of the Affections, and the Opinion of the Peripatetics Respecting Them.

 Chap. XVI.—Of the Affections, and the Refutation of the Opinion of the Peripatetics Concerning Them What is the Proper Use of the Affections, and Wha

 Chap. XVII.—Of the Affections and Their Use Of Patience, and the Chief Good of Christians.

 Chap. XVIII.—Of Some Commands of God, and of Patience.

 Chap. XIX.—Of the Affections and Their Use And of the Three Furies.

 Chap. XX.—Of the Senses, and Their Pleasures in the Brutes and in Man And of Pleasures of the Eyes, and Spectacles.

 Chap. XXI.—Of the Pleasures of the Ears, and of Sacred Literature.

 Chap. XXII.—Of the Pleasures of Taste and Smell.

 Chap. XXIII. —De Tactus Voluptate Et Libidine, Atque de Matrimonio Et Continentiâ.

 Chap. XXIV.—Of Repentance, of Pardon, and the Commands of God.

 Chap. XXV.—Of Sacrifice, and of an Offering Worthy of God, and of the Form of Praising God.

 The Divine Institutes.

 Chap. I.—Of the World, and Those Who are About to Believe, and Those Who are Not And in This the Censure of the Faithless.

 Chap. II.—Of the Error of the Philosophers, and of the Divine Wisdom, and of the Golden Age.

 Chap. III.—Of Nature, and of the World And a Censure of the Stoics and Epicureans.

 Chap. IV.—That All Things Were Created for Some Use, Even Those Things Which Appear Evil On What Account Man Enjoys Reason in So Frail a Body.

 Chap. V.—Of the Creation of Man, and of the Arrangement of the World, and of the Chief Good.

 Chap. VI.—Why the World and Man Were Created. How Unprofitable is the Worship of False Gods.

 Chap. VII.—Of the Variety of Philosophers, and Their Truth.

 Chap. VIII.—Of the Immortality of the Soul.

 Chap. IX.—Of the Immortality of the Soul, and of Virtue.

 Chap. X.—Of Vices and Virtues, and of Life and Death.

 Chap. XI.—Of the Last Times, and of the Soul and Body.

 Chap. XII.—Of the Soul and the Body, and of Their Union and Separation and Return.

 Chap. XIII.—Of the Soul, and the Testimonies Concerning Its Eternity.

 Chap. XIV.—Of the First and Last Times of the World.

 Chap. XV.—Of the Devastation of the World and Change of the Empires.

 CHAP. XVI.—OF THE DEVASTATION of the World, and Its Prophetic Omens.

 Chap. XVII.—Of the False Prophet, and the Hardships of the Righteous, and His Destruction.

 Chap. XVIII.—Of the Fortunes of the World at the Last Time, and of the Things Foretold by the Soothsayers.

 Chap. XIX.—Of the Advent of Christ to Judgment, and of the Overcoming of the False Prophet.

 Chap. XX.—Of the Judgment of Christ, of Christians, and of the Soul.

 Chap. XXI.—Of the Torments and Punishments of Souls.

 Chap. XXII.—Of the Error of the Poets, and the Return of the Soul from the Lower Regions.

 Chap. XXIII.—Of the Resurrection of the Soul, and the Proofs of This Fact.

 Chap. XXIV.—Of the Renewed World.

 Chap. XXV.—Of the Last Times, and of the City of Rome.

 Chap. XXVI.—Of the Loosing of the Devil, and of the Second and Greatest Judgment.

 Chap. XXVII.—An Encouragement and Confirmation of the Pious.

 The Epitome of the Divine Institutes.

 The Preface.—The Plan and Purport of the Whole Epitome, And of the Institutions.

 Chap. I.—Of the Divine Providence.

 Chap. II.—That There is But One God, and that There Cannot Be More.

 Chap. III.—The Testimonies of the Poets Concerning the One God.

 Chap. IV.—The Testimonies of the Philosophers to the Unity of God.

 Chap. V.—That the Prophetic Women—That Is, the Sibyls—Declare that There is But One God.

 Chap. VI.—Since God is Eternal and Immortal, He Does Not Stand in Need of Sex and Succession.

 Chap. VII.—Of the Wicked Life and Death of Hercules.

 Chap. VIII.—Of Æsculapius, Apollo, Mars, Castor and Pollux, and of Mercurius and Bacchus.

 Chap. IX.—Of the Disgraceful Deeds of the Gods.

 Chap. X.—Of Jupiter, and His Licentious Life.

 Chap. XI.—The Various Emblems Under Which the Poets Veiled the Turpitude of Jupiter.

 Chap. XII.—The Poets Do Not Invent All Those Things Which Relate to the Gods.

 Chap. XIII.—The Actions of Jupiter are Related from the Historian Euhemerus.

 Chap. XIV.—The Actions of Saturnus and Uranus Taken from the Historians.

 Chap. XX.—Of the Gods Peculiar to the Romans.

 Chap. XXI.—Of the Sacred Rites of the Roman Gods.

 Chap. XXII.—Of the Sacred Rites Introduced by Faunus and Numa.

 Chap. XXIII.—Of the Gods and Sacred Rites of the Barbarians.

 Chap. XXIV.—Of the Origin of Sacred Rites and Superstitions.

 Chap. XXV.—Of the Golden Age, of Images, and Prometheus, Who First Fashioned Man.

 Chap. XXVI.—Of the Worship of the Elements and Stars.

 Chap. XXVII.—Of the Creation, Sin, and Punishment of Man And of Angels, Both Good and Bad.

 Chap. XXVIII.—Of the Demons, and Their Evil Practices.

 Chap. XXIX.—Of the Patience and Providence of God.

 Chap. XXX.—Of False Wisdom.

 Chap. XXXI.—Of Knowledge and Supposition.

 Chap. XXXII.—Of the Sects of Philosophers, and Their Disagreement.

 Chap. XXXIII.—What is the Chief Good to Be Sought in Life.

 Chap. XXXIV.—That Men are Born to Justice.

 Chap. XXXV.—That Immortality is the Chief Good.

 Chap. XXXVI.—Of the Philosophers,—Namely, Epicurus and Pythagoras.

 Chap. XXXVII.—Of Socrates and His Contradiction.

 Chap. XXXVIII.—Of Plato, Whose Doctrine Approaches More Nearly to the Truth.

 Chap. XXXIX.—Of Various Philosophers, and of the Antipodes.

 Chap. XL.—Of the Foolishness of the Philosophers.

 Chap. XLI.—Of True Religion and Wisdom.

 Chap. XLII.—Of Religious Wisdom: the Name of Christ Known to None, Except Himself and His Father.

 Chap. XLIII.—Of the Name of Jesus Christ, and His Twofold Nativity.

 Chap. XLIV.—The Twofold Nativity of Christ is Proved from the Prophets.

 Chap. XLV.—The Power and Works of Christ are Proved from the Scriptures.

 Chap. XLVI.—It is Proved from the Prophets that the Passion and Death of Christ Had Been Foretold.

 Chap. XLVII.—Of the Resurrection of Jesus Christ, the Sending of the Apostles, and the Ascension of the Saviour into Heaven.

 Chap. XLVIII.—Of the Disinheriting of the Jews, and the Adoption of the Gentiles.

 Chap. XLIX.—That God is One Only.

 Chap. L.—Why God Assumed a Mortal Body, and Suffered Death.

 Chap. LI.—Of the Death of Christ on the Cross.

 Chap. LII.—The Hope of the Salvation of Men Consists in the Knowledge of the True God, and of the Hatred of the Heathens Against the Christians.

 Chap. LIII.—The Reasons of the Hatred Against the Christians are Examined and Refuted.

 Chap. LIV.—Of the Freedom of Religion in the Worship of God.

 Chap. LV.—The Heathens Charge Justice with Impiety in Following God.

 Chap. LVI.—Of Justice, Which is the Worship of the True God.

 Chap. LVII.—Of Wisdom and Foolishness.

 Chap. LVIII.—Of the True Worship of God, and Sacrifice.

 Chap. LIX.—Of the Ways of Life, and the First Times of the World.

 Chap. LX.—Of the Duties of Justice.

 Chap. LXI.—Of the Passions.

 Chap. LXII.—Of Restraining the Pleasures of the Senses.

 Chap. LXIII.—That Shows are Most Powerful to Corrupt the Minds.

 Chap. LXIV.—The Passions are to Be Subdued, and We Must Abstain from Forbidden Things.

 Chap. LXV.—Precepts About Those Things Which are Commanded, and of Pity.

 Chap. LXVI.—Of Faith in Religion, and of Fortitude.

 Chap. LXVII.—Of Repentance, the Immortality of the Soul, and of Providence.

 Chap. LXVIII.—Of the World, Man, and the Providence of God.

 Chap. LXIX.—That the World Was Made on Account of Man, and Man on Account of God.

 Chap. LXX.—The Immortality of the Soul is Confirmed.

 Chap. LXXI.—Of the Last Times.

 Chap. LXXII.—Of Christ Descending from Heaven to the General Judgment, and of the Millenarian Reign.

 Chap. LXXIII.—The Hope of Safety is in the Religion and Worship of God.

Chap. xxi.—of certain deities peculiar to barbarians, and their sacred rites; and in like manner concerning the romans.

We have spoken of the gods themselves who are worshipped; we must now speak a few words respecting their sacrifices and mysteries. Among the people of Cyprus, Teucer sacrificed a human victim to Jupiter, and handed down to posterity that sacrifice which was lately abolished by Hadrian when he was emperor. There was a law among the people of Tauris, a fierce and inhuman nation, by which it was ordered that strangers should be sacrificed to Diana; and this sacrifice was practised through many ages. The Gauls used to appease Hesus and Teutas with human blood. Nor, indeed, were the Latins free from this cruelty, since Jupiter Latialis is even now worshipped with the offering of human blood. What benefit do they who offer such sacrifices implore from the gods? Or what are such deities able to bestow on the men by whose punishments they are propitiated? But this is not so much a matter of surprise with respect to barbarians, whose religion agrees with their character. But are not our countrymen, who have always claimed for themselves the glory of gentleness and civilization, found to be more inhuman by these sacrilegious rites? For these ought rather to be esteemed impious, who, though they are embellished with the pursuits of liberal training, turn aside from such refinement, than those who, being ignorant and inexperienced, glide into evil practices from their ignorance of those which are good. And yet it is plain that this rite of immolating human victims is ancient, since Saturn was honoured in Latium with the same kind of sacrifice; not indeed that a man was slain at the altar, but that he was thrown from the Milvian bridge into the Tiber. And Varro relates that this was done in accordance with an oracle; of which oracle the last verse is to this effect: “And offer heads to Ades, and to the father a man.”68    Or, lights. The oracle is ambiguous, since the word φωσ signifies a man, and also light. [i.e., φὼς = man, and φω̑ς = light.]   And because this appears ambiguous, both a torch and a man are accustomed to be thrown to him. But it is said that sacrifices of this kind were put an end to by Hercules when he returned from Spain; the custom still continuing, that instead of real men, images made from rushes were cast forth, as Ovid informs us in his Fasti:69    v. 629.   “Until the Tirynthian came into these lands, gloomy sacrifices were annually offered in the Leucadian manner: he threw into the water Romans made of straw; do you, after the example of Hercules, cast70    Jace. Others read “jaci.”   in the images of human bodies.”  

The Vestal virgins make these sacred offerings, as the same poet says:71    v. 621.   “Then also a virgin is accustomed to cast from the wooden bridge the images of ancient men made from rushes.”  

For I cannot find language to speak of the infants who were immolated to the same Saturn, on account of his hatred of Jupiter. To think that men were so barbarous, so savage, that they gave the name of sacrifice to the slaughter of their own children, that is, to a deed foul, and to be held in detestation by the human race; since, without any regard to parental affection, they destroyed tender and innocent lives, at an age which is especially pleasing to parents, and surpassed in brutality the savageness of all beasts, which—savage as they are—still love their offspring! O incurable madness! What more could those gods do to them, if they were most angry, than they now do when propitious, when they defile their worshippers with parricide, visit them with bereavements, and deprive them of the sensibilities of men? What can be sacred to these men? Or what will they do in profane places, who commit the greatest crimes amidst the altars of the gods? Pescennius Festus relates in the books of his History by a Satire, that the Carthaginians were accustomed to immolate human victims to Saturn; and when they were conquered by Agathocles, the king of the Sicilians, they imagined that the god was angry with them; and therefore, that they might more diligently offer an expiation, they immolated two hundred sons of their nobles: “So great the ills to which religion could prompt, which has ofttimes produced wicked and impious deeds.” What advantage, then, did the men propose by that sacrifice, when they put to death so large a part of the state, as not even Agathocles had slain when victorious?  

From this kind of sacrifices those public rites are to be judged signs of no less madness; some of which are in honour of the mother of the gods, in which men mutilate themselves; others are in honour of Virtus, whom they also call Bellona, in which the priests make offsprings not with the blood of another victim, but with their own.72    So the priests of Baal cut themselves, 1 Kings xviii. 28.   For, cutting their shoulders, and thrusting forth drawn swords in each hand, they run, they are beside themselves, they are frantic. Quintilian therefore says excellently in his Fanatic: “If a god compels this, he does it in anger.” Are even these things sacred? Is it not better to live like cattle, than to worship deities so impious, profane, and sanguinary? But we will discuss at the proper time the source from which these errors and deeds of such great disgrace originated. In the meantime, let us look also to other matters which are without guilt, that we may not seem to select the worse parts through the desire of finding fault. In Egypt there are sacred rites in honour of Isis, since she either lost or found her little son. For at first her priests, having made their bodies smooth, beat their breasts, and lament, as the goddess herself had done when her child was lost. Afterwards the boy is brought forward, as if found, and that mourning is changed into joy. Therefore Lucan says, “And Osiris never sufficiently sought for.” For they always lose, and they always find him. Therefore in the sacred rites there is a representation of a circumstance which really occurred; and which assuredly declares, if we have any intelligence, that she was a mortal woman, and almost desolate, had she not found one person. And this did not escape the notice of the poet himself; for he represents Pompey when a youth as thus speaking, on hearing the death of his father: “I will now draw forth the deity Isis from the tomb, and send her through the nations; and I will scatter through the people Osiris covered with wood.” This Osiris is the same whom the people call Serapis. For it is customary for the names of the dead who are deified to be changed, that no one, as I believe, may imagine them to be men. For Romulus after his death became Quirinus, and Leda became Nemesis, and Circe Marica; and Ino, when she had leapt into the sea, was called Leucothea; and the mother Matuta; and her son Melicerta was called Palæmon and Portumnus. And the sacred rites of the Eleusinian Ceres are not unlike these. For as in those which have been mentioned the boy Osiris is sought with the wailing of his mother, so in these Proserpine is carried away to contract an incestuous marriage with her uncle; and because Ceres is said to have sought for her in Sicily with torches lighted from the top of Etna, on this account her sacred rites are celebrated with the throwing of torches.  

At Lampsacus the victim to he offered to Priapus is an ass, and the cause of the sacrifice of this animal is thus set forth in the Fasti:—When all the deities had assembled at the festival of the Great Mother, and when, satiated with feasting, they were spending the night in sport, they say that Vesta had laid herself on the ground for rest, and had fallen asleep, and that Priapus upon this formed a design against her honour as she slept; but that she was aroused by the unseasonable braying of the ass on which Silenus used to ride, and that the design of the insidious plotter was frustrated. On this account they say that the people of Lampsacus were accustomed to sacrifice an ass to Priapus, as though it were in revenge; but among the Romans the same animal was crowned at the Vestalia (festival of Vesta) with loaves,73    Panibus, loaves made in the shape of crowns.   in honour of the preservation of her chastity. What is baser, what more disgraceful, than if Vesta is indebted to an ass for the preservation of her purity? But the poet invented a fable. But was that more true which is related by those74    [See this page, note 6, infra.]   who wrote “Phenomena,” when they speak concerning the two stars of Cancer, which the Greeks call asses? That they were asses which carried across father Liber when he was unable to cross a river, and that he rewarded one of them with the power of speaking with human voice; and that a contest arose between him and Priapus; and Priapus, being worsted in the contest, was enraged, and slew the victor. This truly is much more absurd. But poets have the licence of saying what they will. I do not meddle with a mystery so odious; nor do I strip Priapus of his disguise, lest something deserving of ridicule should be brought to light. It is true the poets invented these fictions, but they must have been invented for the purpose of concealing some greater depravity. Let us inquire what this is. But in fact it is evident. For as the bull is sacrificed to Luna,75    The moon.   because he also has horns as she has; and as “Persia propitiates with a horse Hyperion surrounded with rays, that a slow victim may not be offered to the swift god;” so in this case no more suitable victim could be found than that which resembled him to whom it is offered.  

At Lindus, which is a town of Rhodes, there are sacred rites in honour of Hercules, the observance of which differs widely from all other rites; for they are not celebrated with words of good omen76    εὐφημια. It was supposed that words of ill omen, if uttered during the offering of a sacrifice, would render the gods unpropitious: the priest therefore, at the commencement of a sacrifice, called upon the people to abstain from ill-omened words: εὐφημει̑τε, “favete linguis.”   (as the Greeks term it), but with revilings and cursing. And they consider it a violation of the sacred rites, if at any time during the celebration of the solemnities a good word shall have escaped from any one even inadvertently. And this is the reason assigned for this practice, if indeed there can be any reason in things utterly senseless. When Hercules had arrived at the place, and was suffering hunger, he saw a ploughman at work, and began to ask him to sell one of his oxen. But the ploughman replied that this was impossible, because his hope of cultivating the land depended altogether upon those two bullocks. Hercules, with his usual violence, because he was not able to receive one of them, killed both. But the unhappy man, when he saw that his oxen were slain, avenged the injury with revilings,—a circumstance which afforded gratification to the man of elegance and refinement. For while he prepares a feast for his companions, and while he devours the oxen of another man, he receives with ridicule and loud laughter the bitter reproaches with which the other assails him. But when it had been determined that divine honours should be paid to Hercules in admiration of his excellence, an altar was erected in his honour by the citizens, which he named, from the circumstance, the yoke of oxen;77    Βούζυγον.   and at this altar two yoked oxen were sacrificed, like those which he had taken from the ploughman. And he appointed the same man to be his priest, and directed him always to use the same revilings in offering sacrifice, because he said that he had never feasted more pleasantly. Now these things are not sacred, but sacrilegious, in which that is said to be enjoined, which, if it is done in other things, is punished with the greatest severity. What, moreover, do the rites of the Cretan Jupiter himself show, except the manner in which he was withdrawn from his father, or brought up? There is a goat belonging to the nymph Amalthea, which gave suck to the infant; and of this goat Germanicus Cæsar thus speaks, in his poem translated from Aratus:78    Aratus was the author of two Greek astronomical poems, the Φαινόμενα and the Διοσημε̑ια Virgil, in his Georgics, has borrowed largely from the latter. Germanicus Cæsar, the grandson of Augustus, as stated in the text, translated the Φαινόμενα.  —  

“She is supposed to be the nurse of Jupiter; if in truth the infant Jupiter pressed the faithful teats of the Cretan goat, which attests the gratitude of her lord by a bright constellation.”

Musæus relates that Jupiter, when fighting against the Titans, used the hide of this goat as a shield, from which circumstance he is called by the poets shield-bearer.79    αιγιοχος; “scutum habens.”   Thus, whatever was done in concealing the boy, that also is done by way of representation in the sacred rites. Moreover, the mystery of his mother also contains the same story which Ovid sets forth in the Fasti:—  

“Now the lofty Ida resounds with tinklings, that the boy may cry in safety with infant mouth. Some strike their shields with stakes, some beat their empty helmets. This is the employment of the Curetes, this of the Corybantes. The matter was concealed, and imitations of the ancient deed remain; the attendant goddesses shake instruments of brass, and hoarse hides. Instead of helmets they strike cymbals, and drums instead of shields; the flute gives Phrygian strains, as it gave before.”

Sallust rejected this opinion altogether, as though invented by the poets, and wished to give an ingenious explanation of the reasons for which the Curetes are said to have nourished Jupiter; and he speaks to this purport: Because they were the first to understand the worship of the deity, that therefore antiquity, which exaggerates all things, made them known as the nourishers of Jupiter. How much this learned man was mistaken, the matter itself at once declares. For if Jupiter holds the first place, both among the gods and in religious rites, if no gods were worshipped by the people before him, because they who are worshipped were not yet born; it appears that the Curetes, on the contrary, were the first who did not understand the worship of the deity, since all error was introduced by them, and the memory of the true God was taken away. They ought therefore to have understood from the mysteries and ceremonies themselves, that they were offering prayers to dead men. I do not then require that any one should believe the fictions of the poets. If any one imagines that these speak falsely, let him consider the writings of the pontiffs themselves, and weigh whatever there is of literature pertaining to sacred rites: he will perhaps find more things than we bring forward, from which he may understand that all things which are esteemed sacred are empty, vain, and fictitious. But if any one, having discovered wisdom, shall lay aside his error, he will assuredly laugh at the follies of men who are almost without understanding: I mean those who either dance with unbecoming gestures, or run naked, anointed, and crowned with chaplets, either wearing a mask or besmeared with mud. What shall I say about shields now putrid with age? When they carry these, they think that they are carrying gods themselves on their shoulders. For Furius Bibaculus is regarded among the chief examples of piety, who, though he was prætor, nevertheless carried the sacred shield,80    Ancile, the sacred shield, carried by the Salii, or priests of Mars, in the processions at the festival of that deity.   preceded by the lictors, though his office as prœtor gave him an exemption from this duty. He was therefore not Furius, but altogether mad,81    Non Furius, sed plane furiosus.   who thought that he graced his prætorship by this service. Deservedly then, since these things are done by men not unskilful and ignorant, does Lucretius exclaim:—  

“O foolish minds of men! O blinded breasts! In what darkness of life and in how great dangers is passed this term of life, whatever be its duration!”

Who that is possessed of any sense would not laugh at these mockeries, when he sees that men, as though bereft of intelligence, do those things seriously, which if any one should do in sport, he would appear too full of sport and folly?  

0230A CAPUT XXI. De diis Barbarorum quibusdam propriis, et eorum sacris, ac itidem de Romanis.

Diximus de diis ipsis, qui coluntur: nunc de sacris ac mysteriis eorum pauca dicenda sunt. Apud Cyprios humanam hostiam Jovi Teucrus immolavit; idque sacrificium posteris tradidit, quod est nuper Hadriano imperante sublatum. Erat lex apud Tauros, inhumanam et feram gentem, uti Dianae hospites immolarentur; et id sacrificium multis temporibus celebratum est. Galli Hesum atque Teutatem humano cruore placabant. Nec Latini quidem hujus immanitatis expertes fuerunt, siquidem Latialis Jupiter 0231A etiamnunc sanguine colitur humano. Quid a diis boni precantur, qui sic sacrificant? 0231A Aut quid tales dii hominibus praestare possunt, quorum poenis propitiantur? Sed de Barbaris non est adeo mirandum, quorum religio cum moribus congruit. Nostri vero, qui semper mansuetudinis et humanitatis gloriam sibi vindicarunt, nonne sacrilegis his sacris immaniores reperiuntur? Hi enim potius scelerati sunt habendi, qui, cum sint liberalium disciplinarum studiis expoliti, ab humanitate desciscunt, quam qui rudes et imperiti ad mala facinora bonorum ignoratione labuntur. Apparet tamen antiquum esse hunc immolandorum hominum ritum: siquidem Saturnus in Latio eodem genere sacrificii cultus est, non quidem ut homo ad aram immolaretur, sed uti in Tiberim de ponte Milvio mitteretur. Quod ex responso quodam factitatum Varro auctor est; cujus responsi ultimus versus est talis: 0231B Καὶ κεφαλὰς Ἀΐδῃ καὶ τῷ πατρὶ πέμπετε φωτα.0232A Quod quia videtur ambiguum et fax illi, et homo jaci solet. Verum id genus sacrificii ab Hercule, cum ex Hispania rediret, dicitur esse sublatum, ritu tamen permanente, ut pro veris hominibus imagines jacerentur ex scirpo; ut Ovidius in Fastis docet: Donec in haec venit Tirynthius arva, quotannis Tristia Leucadio sacra peracta modo. Illum stramineos in aquam misisse Quirites: Herculis exemplo corpora falsa jace.Haec sacra Vestales virgines faciunt, ut ait idem! Tum quoque priscorum virgo simulacra virorum Mittere roboreo scirpea ponte solet.Nam de infantibus, qui eidem Saturno immolabantur propter odium Jovis quid dicam, non invenio; tam barbaros, tam immanes fuisse homines, ut parricidium suum, id est tetrum atque execrabile humano generi facinus, 0232B sacrificium vocarent: cum teneras atque innocentes 0233A animas, quae maxime est aetas parentibus dulcior, 0233A sine ullo respectu pietatis extinguerent, immanitatemque omnium bestiarum, quae tamen foetus suos amant, feritate superarent! O dementiam insanabilem! Quid illis isti dii amplius facere possent, si essent iratissimi, quam faciunt propitii? cum suos cultores parricidiis inquinant, orbitatibus mactant, humanis sensibus spoliant? Quid potest esse his hominibus sancti? Aut quid in profanis locis facient, qui inter aras deorum summa scelera committunt? Pescennius Festus in libris Historiarum per Satyram refert, Carthaginenses Saturno humanas hostias solitos immolare: et cum victi essent ab Agathocle, rege Siculorum, iratum sibi Deum putavisse; itaque ut diligentius piaculum solverent, ducentos nobilium filios immolasse. Tantum relligio potuit suadere malorum, 0233B Quae peperit saepe scelerosa, atque impia facta.Cui ergo dementissimi homines illo sacrificio consulebant? 0234A cum tantam partem civitatis occiderent, quantam fortasse ne Agathocles quidem victor occiderat.

Ab isto genere sacrorum non minoris insaniae judicanda sunt publica illa sacra: quorum alia sunt matris deum, in quibus homines suis ipsi virilibus litant; amputato enim sexu, nec viros se, nec foeminas faciunt: alia Virtutis, quam eamdem Bellonam vocant, in quibus ipsi sacerdotes non alieno, sed suo cruore sacrificant. Sectis namque humeris, et utraque manu districtos gladios exerentes, currunt, efferuntur, insaniunt. Optime igitur Quintilianus in Fanatico; «Istud, inquit, si Deus cogit, iratus est.» Etiamne haec sacra sunt? Nonne satius est pecudum more vivere, quam deos tam impios, tam profanos, tam sanguinarios colere? Sed unde isti errores et 0234B haec tanta flagitia manaverint, suo loco disseremus: interim videamus et caetera, quae carent scelere, ne 0235A studio insectandi videamur eligere pejora. 0235A Isidis Aegyptia sacra sunt, quatenus filium parvulum vel perdiderit, vel invenerit. Nam primo sacerdotes ejus, deglabrato corpore, pectora sua tundunt; lamentantur, sicut ipsa, cum perdidit, fecerat. Deinde puer producitur quasi inventus, et in laetitiam luctus ille mutatur: ideo Lucanus: . . . . Nunquamque satis quaesitus Osiris.Semper enim perdunt, et semper inveniunt. Refertur ergo in sacris imago rei, quae vere gesta est, quae profecto, si quid sapimus, declarat mortalem mulierem fuisse, ac pene orbam, nisi unicum reperisset. Quod 0236A illum ipsum poetam minime fugit, apud quem Pompeius adolescens, morte patris audita, haec loquitur: Evolvam busto jam numen gentibus Isim; Et tectum ligno spargam per vulgus Osirim.Hic est Osiris, quem Serapim vel Serapidem vulgus appellat. Solent enim mortuis consecratis nomina immutari; credo, ne quis putet eos homines fuisse. Nam et Romulus post mortem Quirinus factus est; et Leda, Nemesis; et Circe, Marica; et Ino, postquam se praecipitavit, Leucothea, materque Matuta; et Melicertes filius ejus, Palaemon, atque Portumnus. 0237A Sacra vero Cereris Eleusinae 0237A non sunt his dissimilia. Nam sicut ibi Osiris puer planctu matris inquiritur; ita hic ad incestum patrui matrimonium rapta Proserpina: quam quia facibus ex Aetnae vertice accensis quaesisse in Sicilia Ceres dicitur, idcirco sacra ejus ardentium taedarum jactatione celebrantur.

Apud Lampsacum Priapo litabilis victima est asellus: cujus sacrificii ratio in Fastis haec redditur: Cum dii omnes ad festum matris magnae convenissent, epulisque satiati noctem lusibus ducerent, quievisse humi Vestam, somnumque cepisse: ibi Priapum somno ejus ac pudicitiae insidiatum; sed illam intempestivo clamore aselli, quo Silenus vehebatur excitatam, libidinem vero insidiatoris esse deceptam; hac de causa Lampsacenos asellum Priapo, quasi in ultionem, mactare consuevisse; apud Romanos vero 0237B eumdem Vestalibus sacris in honorem pudicitiae conservatae panibus coronari. Quid turpius? quid flagitiosius? quam si Vesta beneficio asini virgo est? At poeta fabulam finxit. Num ergo illud est verius, quod referunt ii, qui Φαινόμενα conscripserunt, cum de duabus Cancri stellis loquuntur, quas Graeci ὄνους 0238A vocant? asellos fuisse, qui Liberum patrem transvexerint, cum amnem transire non posset; quorum alteri hoc praemium dederit, ut humana voce loqueretur: itaque inter eum, Priapumque ortum esse certamen de obscoeni magnitudine; Priapum victum et iratum, interemisse victorem. Hoc vero multo magis ineptum est; sed poetis licet quidquid velint: non excutio tam deforme mysterium, nec Priapum denudo, ne quid appareat risu dignum. Finxerunt haec sane poetae; sed necesse est alicujus majoris turpitudinis tegendae gratia ficta sint. Quae sit ergo quaeramus. At ea profecto manifesta est. Nam sicut Lunae taurus mactatur, quia similiter habet cornua, et Placat equo Persis radiis Hyperiona cinctum, Ne detur celeri victima tarda Deo.0238B Ita in hoc quia magnitudo membri virilis enormis est, non potuit ei monstro aptior victima reperiri, quam quae ipsum, cui mactatur, posset imitari.

Apud Lindum, quod est oppidum Rhodi, Herculis sacra sunt, quorum a caeteris longe diversus est ritus: siquidem non εὐφημίᾳ (ut Graeci appellant), sed maledictis, et execratione celebrantur; eaque 0239A pro violatis habent, si quando inter solemnes ritus vel imprudenti alicui exciderit bonum verbum. Cujus rei haec ratio redditur, si tamen ulla esse 0239A in rebus vanissimis potest: Hercules, cum eo delatus esset, famemque pateretur, aratorem quemdam aspexit operantem, ab eoque petere coepit, ut sibi unum bovem venderet. Enimvero ille negavit fieri posse, quia spes sua omnis colendae terrae duobus illis juvencis niteretur. Hercules, solita violentia usus, quia unum accipere non potuit, utrumque sustulit. At ille infelix, cum boves suos mactari videret, injuriam suam maledictis ultus est. Quod homini eleganti et urbano gratissimum fuit. Nam dum comitibus suis epulas apparat, dumque alienos boves devorat, illum sibi amarissime conviciantem, cum risu et cachinnis 0239B audiebat. Sed postquam Herculi divinos honores ob admirationem virtutis deferri placuit, a civibus ei ara posita est, quam de facto βούζυγον nominavit, ad quam duo juncti boves immolarentur, sicut illi quos abstulerat aratori; eumque ipsum sibi constituit sacerdotem, ac praecepit, ut iisdem maledictis semper in celebrandis sacrificiis uteretur, quod negaret se unquam epulatum esse jucundius. Haec jam non sacra sunt, sed sacrilegia, in quibus id sanctum dicitur, quod in aliis, si fiat, etiam severissime vindicatur. Ipsius autem Cretici Jovis sacra quid aliud 0240A quam quomodo sit aut subtractus patri, aut nutritus ostendunt? Capella est Amaltheae nymphae, quae uberibus suis aluit infantem; de qua Germanicus Caesar in Arataeo carmine sic ait: . . . . . Illa putatur Nutrix esse Jovis; si vere Juppiter infans Ubera Cretaeae mulsit fidissima caprae, Sidere quae claro gratum testatur alumnum.Hujus capellae corio usum esse pro scuto Jovem contra Titanas dimicantem Musaeus auctor est: unde a poetis ἀιγίοχος nominatur. Ita quidquid est gestum in abscondendo puero, id ipsum per imaginem geritur in sacris. Sed et matris ejus mysterium idem continet, quod Ovidius exponit in Fastis, lib. IV, v. 207): Ardua jamdudum resonat tinnitibus Ide; 0240B Tutus ut infanti vagiat ore puer. Pars clypeos sudibus, galeas pars tundit inanes: Hoc Curetes habent, hoc Corybantes opus. Res latuit, priscique manent imitamina facti; Aera deae comites raucaque terga movent, Cymbala pro galeis, pro scutis tympana pulsant: Tibia dat Phrygios, ut dedit ante, modos.Hanc totam opinionem, quasi a poetis fictam, Salustius respuit, voluitque ingeniose interpretari, cur altores Jovis dicantur Curetes fuisse; et sic ait: Quia principes intelligendi divini fuerunt, vetustatem ut caetera in majus componentem, altores Jovis celebravisse. Quantum erraverit homo eruditus, jam res 0241A ipsa declarat. Si enim princeps est Jupiter, et deorum et religionum; si ante illum dii nulli colebantur vulgo, quia nondum nati fuerant, qui coluntur; apparet Curetes 0241A ex diverso principes fuisse divini non intelligendi, per quos error omnis inductus est, et Dei veri memoria sublata. Ex ipsis itaque mysteriis et ceremoniis intelligere debuerunt, hominibus se mortuis supplicare. Non igitur exigo, ut aliquis poetarum fictionibus credat. Qui hos mentiri putat, Pontificum ipsorum scripta consideret, et quidquid est litterarum ad sacra pertinentium revolvat: plura fortasse, quam nos afferimus, inveniet, ex quibus intelligat, inania inepta, commentitia esse omnia, quae pro sanctis habentur. Si quis autem, percepta sapientia, deposuerit errorem, profecto ridebit ineptias hominum pene dementium; illos dico, qui vel inhonesto saltatu tripudiant, 0241B vel qui nudi, uncti, coronati, personati, aut luto obliti currunt. Quid de scutis jam vetustate putridis dicam? quae cum portant, deos ipsos se gestare humeris suis arbitrantur. Nam Furius Bibaculus inter 0242A praecipua pietatis exempla numeratur, qui cum praetor esset, tamen lictoribus praeeuntibus, ancile portavit, cum haberet, magistratus beneficio, muneris ejus vacationem. Non ergo ille Furius, sed plane furiosus fuit, qui praeturam hoc ministerio se putavit ornare. Merito igitur, cum haec a viris non imperitis ac rudibus fiant, Lucretius exclamat: O stultas hominum mentes, o pectora caeca! Qualibus in tenebris vitae, quantisque periclis Degitur hoc aevi, quodcumque est!Quis haec ludibria non rideat, qui habeat aliquid sanitatis? cum videat homines velut mente captos ea serio facere, quae si quis faciat in lusu, nimis lascivus et ineptus esse videatur.