The Ecclesiastical History of Theodoret.

 Book I

 The ECCLESIASTICAL HistorY of Theodoret.

 Chapter I.— Origin of the Arian Heresy.

 Chapter II.— List of the Principal Bishops

 Chapter III.— The Epistle of Alexander, Bishop of Alexandria to Alexander, Bishop of Constantinople .

 Chapter IV.— The Letter of Arius to Eusebius, Bishop of Nicomedia

 Chapter V.— The Letter of Eusebius, Bishop of Nicomedia, to Paulinus, Bishop of Tyre .

 Chapter VI.— General Council of Nicæa .

 Chapter VII.— Confutation of Arianism deduced from the Writings of Eustathius and Athanasius .

 Chapter VIII.— Facts relating to Meletius the Egyptian, from whom originated the Meletian Schism, which remains to this day.—Synodical Epistle respect

 Chapter IX.— The Epistle of the Emperor Constantine, concerning the matters transacted at the Council, addressed to those Bishops who were not present

 Chapter X.— The daily wants of the Church supplied by the Emperor, and an account of his other virtues .

 Chapter XI

 Chapter XII.— Confutation of the blasphemies of the Arians of our time, from the writings of Eusebius, Bishop of Cæsarea .

 Chapter XIII.— Extract from the Letter of Athanasius on the Death of Arius .

 Chapter XIV.— Letter written by the Emperor Constantine respecting the building of Churches .

 Chapter XV.— The Epistle of Constantine concerning the preparation of copies of the Holy Scriptures .

 Chapter XVI.— Letter from the Emperor to Macarius, Bishop of Jerusalem, concerning the building of the Holy Church .

 Chapter XVII.— Helena , Mother of the Emperor Constantine.—Her zeal in the Erection of the Holy Church .

 Chapter XVIII.— The Unlawful Translation of Eusebius, Bishop of Nicomedia .

 Chapter XIX.— Epistle of the Emperor Constantine against Eusebius and Theognis, addressed to the Nicomedians .

 Chapter XX.— The artful Machinations of Eusebius and his followers against the Holy Eustathius, Bishop of Antioch .

 Chapter XXI.— Bishops of Heretical opinions ordained in Antioch after the Banishment of St. Eustathius .

 Chapter XXII.— Conversion of the Indians .

 Chapter XXIII.— Conversion of the Iberians .

 Chapter XXIV.— Letter written by the Emperor Constantine to Sapor , the King of Persia, respecting the Christians .

 Chapter XXV.— An account of the plot formed against the Holy Athanasius .

 Chapter XXVI.— Another plot against Athanasius .

 Chapter XXVII.— Epistle of the Emperor Constantine to the Council of Tyre .

 Chapter XXVIII.— The Council of Tyre .

 Chapter XXIX.— Consecration of the Church of Jerusalem.—Banishment of St. Athanasius .

 Chapter XXX.— Will of the blessed Emperor Constantine .

 Chapter XXXI.— Apology for Constantine .

 Chapter XXXII.— The End of the Holy Emperor Constantine .

 Book II

 Book II.

 Chapter II.— Declension of the Emperor Constantius from the true Faith .

 Chapter III.— Second Exile of St. Athanasius.—Ordination and Death of Gregorius .

 Chapter IV.— Paulus, Bishop of Constantinople .

 Chapter V.— The Heresy of Macedonius .

 Chapter VI.— Council held at Sardica .

 Chapter VII.— Account of the Bishops Euphratas and Vincentius, and of the plot formed in Antioch against them .

 Chapter VIII.— Stephanus Deposed .

 Chapter IX.— The Second Return of Saint Athanasius .

 Chapter X.— Third exile and flight of Athanasius .

 Chapter XI.— The evil and daring deeds done by Georgius in Alexandria.

 Chapter XII.— Council of Milan .

 Chapter XIII.— Conference between Liberius, Pope of Rome, and the Emperor Constantius .

 Chapter XIV.— Concerning the Banishment and Return of the Holy Liberius .

 Chapter XV.— Council of Ariminum .

 Chapter XVI.— Concerning the Synod held at Nica in Thrace, and the Confession of Faith drawn up there .

 Chapter XVII.— Synodical Act of Damasus, Bishop of Rome, and of the Western Bishops, about the Council at Ariminum .

 Chapter XVIII.— The Letter of Athanasius, Bishop of Alexandria, concerning the same Council.

 Chapter XIX.— Concerning the cunning of Leontius, Bishop of Antioch, and the boldness of Flavianus and Diodorus .

 Chapter XX.— Concerning the innovations of Eudoxius, of Germanicia, and the zeal of Basilius .

 Chapter XXI.— Of the Second Council of Nicæa .

 Chapter XXII.— Of the Council held at Seleucia in Isauria .

 Chapter XXIII.— Of what befell the orthodox bishops at Constantinople .

 Chapter XXIV.— Synodical Epistle written against Aetius .

 Chapter XXV.— Of the causes which separated the Eunomians from the Arians .

 Chapter XXVI.— Of the siege of the city of Nisibis, and the apostolic conversation of Bishop Jacobus .

 Chapter XXVII.— Of the Council of Antioch and what was done there against the holy Meletius .

 Chapter XXVIII.— About Eusebius, Bishop of Samosata .

 Book III

 Book III.

 Chapter II.— Of the return of the bishops and the consecration of Paulinus .

 Chapter III.— Of the number and character of the deeds done by Pagans against the Christians when they got the power from Julian .

 Chapter IV.— Of the laws made by Julian against the Christians .

 Chapter V.— Of the fourth exile and flight of the holy Athanasius .

 Chapter VI.— Of Apollo and Daphne, and of the holy Babylas .

 Chapter VII.— Of Theodorus the Confessor .

 Chapter VIII.— Of the confiscation of the sacred treasures and taking away of the allowances .

 Chapter IX.— Of what befell Julianus, the Emperor’s Uncle, and Felix .

 Chapter X.— Of the Son of the Priest .

 Chapter XI.— Of the Holy Martyrs Juventinus and Maximinus .

 Chapter XII.— Of Valentinianus the great Emperor .

 Chapter XIII.— Of other confessors .

 Chapter XIV.— Of Artemius the Duke. Of Publia the Deaconess and her divine boldness .

 Chapter XV.— Of the Jews of their attempt at building, and of the heaven-sent plagues that befel them .

 Chapter XVI.— Of the expedition against the Persians .

 Chapter XVII.— Of the boldness of speech of the decurion of Berœa .

 Chapter XVIII.— Of the prediction of the pedagogue .

 Chapter XIX.— Of the Prophecy of St. Julianus the monk .

 Chapter XX.— Of the death of the Emperor Julian in Persia .

 Chapter XXI.— Of the sorcery at Carræ which was detected after his death. After he was slain the jugglery of his sorcery was detected. For Carræ is a

 Chapter XXII.— Of the heads discovered in the palace at Antioch and the public rejoicings there .

 Book IV

 Book IV.

 Chapter II.— Of the return of Athanasius .

 Chapter III.— Synodical letter to the Emperor Jovian concerning the Faith .

 Chapter IV.— Of the restoration of allowances to the churches and of the Emperor’s death.

 Chapter V.— Of the reign of Valentinianus, and how he associated Valens his brother with him.

 Chapter VI.— Of the election of Ambrosius, the Bishop of Milan .

 Chapter VII.— Letters of the Emperors Valentinianus and Valens, written to the diocese of Asia about the Homoüsion , on hearing that some men in Asia

 Chapter VIII.— Synodical Epistle of the Synod in Illyricum concerning the Faith .

 Chapter IX.— Of the heresy of the Audiani .

 Chapter X.— Of the heresy of the Messaliani .

 Chapter XI.— In what manner Valens fell into heresy .

 Chapter XII.— How Valens exiled the virtuous bishops .

 Chapter XIII.— Of Eusebius, bishop of Samosata, and others .

 Chapter XIV.— Of the holy Barses, and of the exile of the bishop of Edessa and his companions .

 Chapter XV.— Of the persecution which took place at Edessa, and of Eulogius and Protogenes, presbyters of Edessa .

 Chapter XVI.— Of the holy Basilius, Bishop of Cæsarea, and the measures taken against him by Valens and the prefect Modestus .

 Chapter XVII.— Of the death of the great Athanasius and the election of Petrus .

 Chapter XVIII.— On the overthrow of Petrus and the introduction of Lucius the Arian .

 Chapter XIX.— Narrative of events at Alexandria in the time of Lucius the Arian, taken from a letter of Petrus, Bishop of Alexandria .

 Chapter XX.— Of Mavia, Queen of the Saracens, and the ordination of Moses the monk.

 Chapter XXI

 Chapter XXII.— How Flavianus and Diodorus gathered the church of the orthodox in Antioch .

 Chapter XXIII.— Of the holy monk Aphraates .

 Chapter XXIV.— Of the holy monk Julianus .

 Chapter XXV.— Of what other monks were distinguished at this period .

 Chapter XXVI.— Of Didymus of Alexandria and Ephraim the Syrian .

 Chapter XXVII.— Of what bishops were at this time distinguished in Asia and Pontus.

 Chapter XXVIII.— Of the letter written by Valens to the great Valentinianus about the war, and how he replied .

 Chapter XXIX.— Of the piety of Count Terentius .

 Chapter XXX.— Of the bold utterance of Trajanus the general .

 Chapter XXXI.— Of Isaac the monk of Constantinople and Bretanio the Scythian Bishop.

 Chapter XXXII.— Of the expedition of Valens against the Goths and how he paid the penalty of his impiety .

 Chapter XXXIII.— How the Goths became tainted by the Arian error .

 Book V

 Book V.

 Chapter II.— Of the return of the bishops .

 Chapter III.— Of the dissension caused by Paulinus of the innovation by Apollinarius of Laodicea, and of the philosophy of Meletius .

 Chapter IV.— Of Eusebius Bishop of Samosata .

 Chapter V.— Of the campaign of Theodosius .

 Chapter VI.— Of the reign of Theodosius and of his dream .

 Chapter VII.— Of famous leaders of the Arian faction.

 Chapter VIII.— The council assembled at Constantinople .

 Chapter IX.— Synodical letter from the council at Constantinople .

 Chapter X.— Synodical letter of Damasus bishop of Rome against Apollinarius and Timotheus.

 Chapter XI.— A confession of the Catholic faith which Pope Damasus sent to Bishop Paulinus in Macedonia when he was at Thessalonica .

 Chapter XII.— Of the death of Gratianus and the sovereignty of Maximus

 Chapter XIII.— Of Justina, the wife of Valentinianus, and of her plot against Ambrosius.

 Chapter XIV.— Of the information given by Maximus the tyrant to Valentinianus .

 Chapter XV.— Of the Letter written by the Emperor Theodosius concerning the same .

 Chapter XVI.— Of Amphilochius, bishop of Iconium .

 Chapter XVII.— Of the massacre of Thessalonica the boldness of Bishop Ambrosius, and the piety of the Emperor .

 Chapter XVIII.— Of the Empress Placilla .

 Chapter XIX.— Of the sedition of Antioch .

 Chapter XX.— Of the destruction of the temples all over the Empire.

 Chapter XXI.— Of Marcellus, bishop of Apamea, and the idols’ temples destroyed by him.

 Chapter XXII.— Of Theophilus, bishop of Alexandria, and what happened at the demolition of the idols in that city .

 Chapter XXIII.— Of Flavianus bishop of Antioch and of the sedition which arose in the western Church on account of Paulinus .

 Chapter XXIV.— Of the tyranny of Eugenius and the victory won through faith by the Emperor Theodosius .

 Chapter XXV.— Of the death of the Emperor Theodosius .

 Chapter XXVI.— Of Honorius the emperor and Telemachus the monk .

 Chapter XXVII.— Of the piety of the emperor Arcadius and the ordination of John Chrysostom.

 Chapter XXVIII.— Of John’s boldness for God .

 Chapter XXIX.— Of the idol temples which were destroyed by John in Phœnicia .

 Chapter XXX.— Of the church of the Goths .

 Chapter XXXI.— Of his care for the Scythians and his zeal against the Marcionists

 Chapter XXXII.— Of the demand made by Gainas and of John Chrysostom’s reply .

 Chapter XXXIII.— Of the ambassage of Chrysostom to Gainas .

 Chapter XXXIV.— Of the events which happened on account of Chrysostom .

 Chapter XXXV.— Of Alexander, bishop of Antioch .

 Chapter XXXVI.— Of the removal of the remains of John and of the faith of Theodosius and his sisters .

 Chapter XXXVII.— Of Theodotus bishop of Antioch .

 Chapter XXXVIII.— Of the persecutions in Persia and of them that were martyred there.

 Chapter XXXIX.— Of Theodorus, bishop of Mopsuestia .

Chapter XXXVIII.—Of the persecutions in Persia and of them that were martyred there.

At this time Isdigirdes,714 Yezdegerd I. son of Sapor III. Vide note on p. 156. King of the Persians, began to wage war against the churches and the circumstances which caused him so to do were as follows. A certain bishop, Abdas by name,715 Abdas was bishop of Susa. In Soc. vii. 8 he is “bishop of Persia.” adorned with many virtues, was stirred with undue zeal and destroyed a Pyreum, Pyreum being the name given by the Persians to the temples of the fire which they regarded as their God.716 The second of the six supreme councillors of Ahuramazda in the scheme of Zarathustra Spitama (Zoroaster) is Ardebehesht, light or lightness of any kind and representing the omnipresence of the good power. Hence sun, moon and stars are symbols of deity and the believer is enjoined to face fire or light in his worship. Temples and altars must be fed with holy fire. In their reverence for fire orthodox Parsees abstained from smoking, but alike of old and today they would deny the charge of worshipping fire in any other sense than as an honoured symbol.

On being informed of this by the Magi Isdigirdes sent for Abdas and first in moderate language complained of what had taken place and ordered him to rebuild the Pyreum.

This the bishop, in reply, positively refused to do, and thereupon the king threatened to destroy all the churches, and in the end carried out all his threats, for first he gave orders for the execution of that holy man and then commanded the destruction of the churches. Now I am of opinion that to destroy the Pyreum was wrong and inexpedient, for not even the divine Apostle, when he came to Athens and saw the city wholly given to idolatry, destroyed any one of the altars which the Athenians honoured, but convicted them of their ignorance by his arguments, and made manifest the truth. But the refusal to rebuild the fallen temple, and the determination to choose death rather than so do, I greatly praise and honour, and count to be a deed worthy of the martyr’s crown; for building a shrine in honour of the fire seems to me to be equivalent to adoring it.

From this beginning arose a tempest which stirred fierce and cruel waves against the nurslings of the true faith, and when thirty years had gone by the agitation still remained kept up by the Magi, as the sea is kept in commotion by the blasts of furious winds. Magi is the name given by the Persians to the worshippers of the sun and moon717 The word in the original is στοιχεῖα; on this Valesius annotates “This does not mean the four elements, for the Persian Magi did not worship the four elements but only fire and the sun and moon.” In illustration of this use of the word he quotes Chrysostom. Hom. 58 in Matth. ὁ γὰρ δαίμων ἐπὶ διαβολᾐ τοῦ στοιχείου καὶ ἐπιτίθεται τοῖς ἀλοῦσι, καὶ ἀνίησιν αὐτοὺς κατὰ τοὺς τῆς σελήνης δρόμους; and St. Jerome Ep. ad Hedyb. 4 where he speaks of the days of the week as being described by the heathen “Idolorum et elementorum nominibus.” but I have exposed their fabulous system in another treatise and have adduced solutions of their difficulties.

On the death of Isdigirdes, Vararanes, his son, inherited at once the kingdom and the war against the faith, and dying in his turn left them both together to his son.718 i.e. Isdigirdes II. 440–457. To relate the various kinds of tortures and cruelties inflicted on the saints is no easy task. In some cases the hands were flayed, in others the back; of others they stripped the heads of skin from brow to beard; others were enveloped in split reeds with the cut part turned inwards and were surrounded with tight bandages from head to foot; then each of the reeds was dragged out by force, and, tearing away the adjacent portions of the skin, caused severe agony; pits were dug and carefully greased in which quantities of mice were put; then they let down the martyrs, bound hand and foot, so as not to be able to protect themselves from the animals, to be food for the mice, and the mice, under stress of hunger, little by little devoured the flesh of the victims, causing them long and terrible suffering. By others sufferings were endured even more terrible than these, invented by the enemy of humanity and the opponent of the truth, but the courage of the martyrs was unbroken, and they hastened unbidden in their eagerness to win that death which ushers men into indestructible life.

Of these I will cite one or two to serve as examples of the courage of the rest. Among the noblest of the Persians was one called Hormisdas, by race an Achæmenid719 Achæmenes was the name of the Grandfather of Cambyses, father of Cyrus, and also of a son of Darius, son of Hystaspes. Hence the Achæmenidæ were the noblest stock of Persia. and the son of a Prefect. On receiving information that he was a Christian the king summoned him and ordered him to abjure God his Saviour. He replied that the royal orders were neither right nor reasonable, “for he,” so he went on, “who is taught to find no difficulty in spurning and denying the God of all, will haply the more easily despise a king who is a man of mortal nature; and if, sir, he who denies thy sovereignty is deserving of the severest punishment, how much more terrible a chastisement is not due to him who denies the Creator of the world?” The king ought to have admired the wisdom of what was said, but, instead of this, he stripped the noble athlete of his wealth and rank, and ordered him to go clad in nothing save a loin cloth, and drive the camels of the army. After some days had gone by, as he looked out of his chamber, he saw the excellent man scorched by the rays of the sun, and covered with dust, and he bethought him of his father’s illustrious rank, and sent for him, and told him to put on a tunic of linen. Then thinking the toil he had suffered, and the kindness shewn him, had softened his heart, “Now at least,” said he “give over your opposition, and deny the carpenter’s son.” Full of holy zeal Hormisdas tore the tunic and flung it away saying, “If you think that this will make one give up the true faith, keep your present with your false belief.” When the king saw how bold he was he drove him naked from the palace.

One Suenes, who owned a thousand slaves, resisted the King, and refused to deny his master. The King therefore asked him which of his slaves was the vilest, and to this slave handed over the ownership of all the rest, and gave him Suenes to be his slave. He also gave him in marriage Suenes’ wife, supposing that thus he could bend the will of the champion of the truth. But he was disappointed, for he had built his house upon the rock.720 Matt. vii. 24

The king also seized and imprisoned a deacon of the name of Benjamin. After two years there came an envoy from Rome, to treat of other matters, who, when he was informed of this imprisonment, petitioned the king to release the deacon. The king ordered Benjamin to promise that he would not attempt to teach the Christian religion to any of the Magi, and the envoy exhorted Benjamin to obey, but Benjamin, after he heard what the envoy had to say, replied, “It is impossible for me not to impart the light which I have received; for how great a penalty is due for the hiding of our talent is taught in the history of the holy gospels.”721 Matt. xxv. 25 Up to this time the King had not been informed of this refusal and ordered him to be set free. Benjamin continued as he was wont seeking to catch them that were held down by the darkness of ignorance, and bringing them to the light of knowledge. After a year information of his conduct was given to the king, and he was summoned and ordered to deny Him whom he worshipped. He then asked the king “What punishment should be assigned to one who should desert his allegiance and prefer another?” “Death and torture,” said the king. “How then” continued the wise deacon “should he be treated who abandons his Maker and Creator, makes a God of one of his fellow slaves, and offers to him the honour due to his Lord?” Then the king was moved with wrath, and had twenty reeds pointed, and driven into the nails of his hands and feet. When he saw that Benjamin took this torture for child’s play, he pointed another reed and drove it into his privy part and by working it up and down caused unspeakable agony. After this torture the impious and savage tyrant ordered him to be impaled upon a stout knotted staff, and so the noble sufferer gave up the ghost.

Innumerable other similar deeds of violence were committed by these impious men, but we must not be astonished that the Lord of all endures their savagery and impiety, for indeed before the reign of Constantine the Great all the Roman emperors wreaked their wrath on the friends of the truth, and Diocletian, on the day of the Saviour’s passion, destroyed the churches throughout the Roman Empire, but after nine years had gone by they rose again in bloom and beauty many times larger and more splendid than before, and he and his iniquity perished.722 The edict of Diocletian against the Christians was issued on the feast of the Terminalia, Feb. 23, 303. Good Friday, here ἡ τοῦ σωτηρίου πάθους ἡμέρα, was commonly known as ἡμερα τοῦ σταυροῦ, πάσχα σταυρώσιμον, and παρασκευή Tertullian speaks of its early observance as a general fast, and Eusebius confirms his testimony.

These wars and the victory of the church had been predicted by the Lord, and the event teaches us that war brings us more blessing than peace. Peace makes us delicate, easy and cowardly. War whets our courage and makes us despise this present world as passing away. But these are observations which we have often made in other writings.