On Flight during Persecution.

 1.  My brother Fabius, you very lately asked, because some news or other were communicated, whether or not we ought to flee in persecution.  For my pa

 2.  If, because injustice is not from God, but from the devil, and persecution consists of injustice (for what more unjust than that the bishops of th

 3.  Seeing therefore, too, these cases occur in persecutions more than at other times, as there is then among us more of proving or rejecting, more of

 4.  Well, then, if it is evident from whom persecution proceeds, we are able at once to satisfy your doubts, and to decide from these introductory rem

 5.  But, says some one, I flee, the thing it belongs to me to do, that I may not perish, if I deny it is for Him on His part, if He chooses, to bring

 6.  Nay, says some one, he fulfilled the command, when he fled from city to city.  For so a certain individual, but a fugitive likewise, has chosen to

 7.  Let us now see whether also the rest of our Lord’s ordinances accord with a lasting command of flight.  In the first place, indeed, if persecution

 8.  He sometimes also fled from violence Himself, but for the same reason as had led Him to command the apostles to do so:  that is, He wanted to fulf

 9.  The teaching of the apostles was surely in everything according to the mind of God:  they forgot and omitted nothing of the Gospel.  Where, then,

 10.  But some, paying no attention to the exhortations of God, are readier to apply to themselves that Greek versicle of worldly wisdom, “He who fled

 11.  Thus ought every servant of God to feel and act, even one in an inferior place, that he may come to have a more important one, if he has made som

 12.  So far, my brother, as the question proposed by you is concerned, you have our opinion in answer and encouragement.  But he who inquires whether

 13.  But also to every one who asks me I will give on the plea of charity, not under any intimidation.  Who asks? He says.  But he who uses intimidati

 14.  But how shall we assemble together? say you how shall we observe the ordinances of the Lord?  To be sure, just as the apostles also did, who wer

11.  Thus ought every servant of God to feel and act, even one in an inferior place, that he may come to have a more important one, if he has made some upward step by his endurance of persecution.  But when persons in authority themselves—I mean the very deacons, and presbyters, and bishops—take to flight, how will a layman be able to see with what view it was said, Flee from city to city?  Thus, too, with the leaders turning their backs, who of the common rank will hope to persuade men to stand firm in the battle?  Most assuredly a good shepherd lays down his life for the sheep, according to the word of Moses, when the Lord Christ had not as yet been revealed, but was already shadowed forth in himself:  “If you destroy this people,” he says, “destroy me also along with it.”  But Christ, confirming these foreshadowings Himself, adds:  “The bad shepherd is he who, on seeing the wolf, flees, and leaves the sheep to be torn in pieces.”  Why, a shepherd like this will be turned off from the farm; the wages to have been given him at the time of his discharge will be kept from him as compensation; nay, even from his former savings a restoration of the master’s loss will be required; for “to him who hath shall be given, but from him who hath not shall be taken away even that which he seemeth to have.”  Thus Zechariah threatens:  “Arise, O sword, against the shepherds, and pluck ye out the sheep; and I will turn my hand against the shepherds.”  And against them both Ezekiel and Jeremiah declaim with kindred threatenings, for their not only wickedly eating of the Sheep,—they feeding themselves rather than those committed to their charge,—but also scattering the flock, and giving it over, shepherdless, a prey to all the beasts of the field.  And this never happens more than when in persecution the Church is abandoned by the clergy.  If any one recognises the Spirit also, he will hear him branding the runaways.  But if it does not become the keepers of the flock to flee when the wolves invade it—nay, if that is absolutely unlawful (for He who has declared a shepherd of this sort a bad one has certainly condemned him; and whatever is condemned has, without doubt, become unlawful)—on this ground it will not be the duty of those who have been set over the Church to flee in the time of persecution.  But otherwise, if the flock should flee, the overseer of the flock would have no call to hold his ground, as his doing so in that case would be, without good reason, to give to the flock protection, which it would not require in consequence of its liberty, forsooth, to flee.

CAPUT XI.

Hoc sentire et facere omnem servum Dei oportet, etiam minoris loci, ut majoris fieri possit, 0113B si quem gradum ex persecutionis tolerantia ascenderit. Sed cum ipsi auctores, id est, ipsi diaconi, presbyteri et episcopi fugiunt, quomodo laicus intelligere poterit, qua ratione dictum (Matth. X, 23), Fugite de civitate in civitatem? Itaque cum duces fugiunt, quis de gregario numero sustinebit ad gradum in acie figendum suadentes ? Certe quidem bonus pastor animam pro pecoribus ponit; ut Moyses, non Domino adhuc Christo revelato, etiam in se figurato, ait (Exod. XXXII, 32): Si perdis hunc populum, inquit, et me pariter cum eo disperde. Caeterum, Christo confirmante figuras suas, malus pastor est, qui viso lupo fugit, et pecora diripienda derelinquit (Joan. X, 12): projicietur de villa pastor hujusmodi: detinebuntur illi missionis 0113C suae mercedes in compensationem ; imo et de priore peculio ejus exigetur detrimenti dominici restitutio. Etenim qui habet, dabitur ei; ab eo autem qui non habet, etiam quod videtur habere auferetur (Matth. XIII, 12). Sic Zacharias (XIII, 7) comminatur: Exsurge romphaea in pastores, et evellite oves, superducam manum meam in pastores. In quos et Ezechiel (Ezech. XXXIV, 2) et Hieremias iisdem minis perorant, quod non tantum de pecoribus improbe vescantur, pascentes potius semetipsos, verum quod0114Adispersum gregem faciant in praedam esse omnibus bestiis agri, dum non est pastor illis. Quod nunquam magis fit, quam cum in persecutione destituitur Ecclesia a Clero. Si et Spiritum quis agnoverit, audiet et fugitivos denotantem. Porro, si eos qui gregi praesunt, fugere, cum lupi irruunt, nec decet, imo nec licet (qui enim talem pastorem malum pronuntiavit, utique damnavit, omne autem quod damnatur, illicitum factum est sine dubio), ideo praepositos Ecclesiae in persecutione fugere non oportebit. Caeterum, si grex fugere deberet, non deberet praepositus gregis stare, sine caussa staturus ad tutelam gregis, quam grex non desideraret, ex licentia fugae scilicet.